Class 1 Buybacks vs CAPEX

Class I railroads: cash to shareholders vs. reinvestment, 2022–2025

Over 2022–2025 the six Class I railroads earned — in net income. They paid out — through buybacks and dividends — — of profits — while capital spending came to —, or — of profits.

Share buybacks, 4 years
—
US$, CN & CPKC converted from C$
Dividends (BNSF: distributions to Berkshire)
—
US$, 4 years
Capital expenditures, 4 years
—
Property additions / capital investments
Paid to shareholders per $1 of capex
—
Buybacks + dividends ÷ capex

Four-year totals by railroad (US$ billions)

Each railroad's upper bar is cash returned to shareholders (buybacks + dividends); the lower bar is capital spending. The black tick marks four-year net income.

Buybacks Dividends Capital spending Net income

Share of net income, by year

Above the dashed 100% line, a railroad paid out (or invested) more than it earned that year. Ratios use each company's own currency.

Reported operating ratio (%)

Operating expenses as a share of revenue, as reported (GAAP). Lower means a wider operating margin.

Year-by-year detail (millions, company's reporting currency)

UP, BNSF, CSX and NS report in US$; CN and CPKC in C$. Red marks a year when payouts exceeded net income.

Railroad Year Cur. Net income Buybacks Dividends Capex Payout ÷ NI Capex ÷ NI Op. ratio
Definitions, sources and caveats
  • Net income: reported GAAP net income (BNSF: Burlington Northern Santa Fe, LLC; CPKC: net income attributable to controlling shareholders, derived from reported EPS × diluted shares where an exact figure wasn't retrieved — 2025 ≈ C$4.1B).
  • Buybacks / dividends: cash paid in the year per each company's cash-flow statement. BNSF is wholly owned by Berkshire Hathaway, so it does no buybacks; its "dividends" are cash distributions to Berkshire.
  • Capex: property additions / capital investments from the cash-flow statement (BNSF: capex excluding equipment plus equipment acquisitions; CPKC excludes small Meridian Speedway additions).
  • Operating ratio: reported (unadjusted) figure. Notable one-offs: NS 2023 (76.5%) includes the East Palestine derailment costs (adjusted ≈ 66–67%); BNSF 2024 includes a $290M labor agreement charge; CSX 2025 includes a $164M goodwill impairment; CPKC 2023 reflects merger accounting for Kansas City Southern (consolidated from April 2023; 2022 is CP standalone).
  • Currency: CN and CPKC amounts are converted to US$ only for the four-year totals, using approximate annual-average rates (C$ per US$: 1.301, 1.350, 1.370, 1.398 for 2022–2025). Ratios are unaffected.
  • Sources: 10-K/40-F filings and Q4 earnings releases of each company (UNP, CSX, NSC, CNI, CP), BNSF LLC 10-K filings and Berkshire Hathaway's annual reports. UP 2025 net income ≈ $7.14B (rounded).

Compiled by Backbone Campaign / Solutionary Rail from company filings. Data current as of fiscal 2025 reports.

Class I railroads paid shareholders more than they reinvested in the railroad

From 2022 to 2025, North America's six Class I railroads earned —. For every dollar they spent on track, bridges, locomotives and equipment, they sent — to shareholders.

Four years of profit

Union Pacific, BNSF, CSX, Norfolk Southern, CN and CPKC together earned — in net income from 2022 through 2025, with CN and CPKC converted from Canadian dollars.

Where the money went

— went back to shareholders — — of profits — split between — in stock buybacks and — in dividends. Capital spending came to —, or — of profits.

Railroad by railroad

Union Pacific returned the most, —, against — of capital spending. BNSF has no public shares to buy back; its — went to its owner, Berkshire Hathaway. Only CPKC spent more on its network than it paid out.

Paying out more than they earned

Above the dashed line, a railroad's buybacks and dividends exceeded that year's net income. CN did it three years running, CSX twice. In 2022 Union Pacific paid out — of its profit and Norfolk Southern —.

CPKC sat out, then caught up

While absorbing Kansas City Southern, CPKC paid only its dividend — — of 2023 profit. In 2025 it bought back C$— million of stock, lifting its payout to —.

Reinvestment lagged

Capital spending ran at — of profits overall. It passed 100% only for Norfolk Southern in 2023 (—) and CSX in 2025 (—) — years when their profits fell.

The efficiency scorecard

The operating ratio is operating expenses as a share of revenue; lower is better. Union Pacific finished 2025 at —, the lowest of the six. CSX's rose every year, to —. Norfolk Southern's 2023 spike to — reflects East Palestine derailment costs.

Year-by-year detail (millions, company's reporting currency)

UP, BNSF, CSX and NS report in US$; CN and CPKC in C$. Red marks a year when payouts exceeded net income.

Railroad Year Cur. Net income Buybacks Dividends Capex Payout ÷ NI Capex ÷ NI Op. ratio
Definitions, sources and caveats
  • Net income: reported GAAP net income (BNSF: Burlington Northern Santa Fe, LLC; CPKC: net income attributable to controlling shareholders, derived from reported EPS × diluted shares where an exact figure wasn't retrieved — 2025 ≈ C$4.1B).
  • Buybacks / dividends: cash paid in the year per each company's cash-flow statement. BNSF is wholly owned by Berkshire Hathaway, so it does no buybacks; its "dividends" are cash distributions to Berkshire.
  • Capex: property additions / capital investments from the cash-flow statement (BNSF: capex excluding equipment plus equipment acquisitions; CPKC excludes small Meridian Speedway additions).
  • Operating ratio: reported (unadjusted) figure. Notable one-offs: NS 2023 includes the East Palestine derailment costs (adjusted ≈ 66–67%); BNSF 2024 includes a $290M labor agreement charge; CSX 2025 includes a $164M goodwill impairment; CPKC 2023 reflects merger accounting for Kansas City Southern (consolidated from April 2023; 2022 is CP standalone).
  • Currency: CN and CPKC amounts are converted to US$ only for the four-year totals, using approximate annual-average rates (C$ per US$: 1.301, 1.350, 1.370, 1.398 for 2022–2025). Ratios are unaffected.
  • Sources: 10-K/40-F filings and Q4 earnings releases of each company (UNP, CSX, NSC, CNI, CP), BNSF LLC 10-K filings and Berkshire Hathaway's annual reports. UP 2025 net income ≈ $7.14B (rounded).

Compiled by Backbone Campaign / Solutionary Rail from company filings. Data current as of fiscal 2025 reports.